In the history of Urdu literature, Allama Iqbal stands like a giant tree under whose shade many generations have sought intellectual refuge. However, a great tragedy is also attached to this greatness of Iqbal. This tragedy is the failure to understand his poetry in its true, pure, and inner form. It is generally said about Iqbal that he is a poet of 'thought'. His superficial admirers consider this to be his greatest quality and praise, elevating him above a poet to the status of a philosopher, theologian, and messenger. On the other hand, his critics use this very point to accuse him of not being a poet at all, claiming that he merely tied philosophy and dry ideas into meter and rhyme.
Both of these viewpoints have actually failed to reach the 'Iqbal' who was, first and foremost, simply a true poet. The tragedy is that Iqbal himself sometimes helped cement this misunderstanding by denying that he was a poet. When Iqbal denies his poetic nature, it gives shallow commentators the opportunity to present his poetry merely as a tool or medium. But the truth is that there is a type of poetic experience where the poet becomes familiar with such profound depths of his existence that all powers of expression seem insignificant and helpless before them.
Since poetry is the name of an extremely complex and agonizing experience, many great poets in history have denied being poets. This denial is not actually a rejection of poetry, but an acknowledgment of the pain that is the foundation of poetry. Even a complete poet like Mir Taqi Mir, known as the God of Poetry, said something similar about himself:
Ham ko shayar na kaho Mir ki sahib ham ne
Dard-o-gham kitne kiye jam.a to deewan kiya
This couplet by Mir is a testament to the fact that compiling a poetry collection is not merely a play of words, but the act of gathering a lifetime of sorrows and pain. Iqbal's thought of abandoning poetry or his denial of being a poet was of the same nature. He was afraid of the intensity of the experience that took him into the depths of his being.
By considering Iqbal merely a thinker, we view his living experiences, which were a part of his warm blood, as ready-made, so-called ideas. Iqbal could have been a philosopher, a political thinker, or an economist, but if the storm that rages inside a poet had not erupted within him, he would never have become the Iqbal we know today. Not valuing him for his poetic genius is a great tragedy of our cultural life.
In the history of Urdu literature, Allama Iqbal stands like a giant tree under whose shade many generations hawe sought intellectual refuge Howewer, a great tragedy is also attached to this greatness of Iqbal This tragedy is the failure to understand his poetry in its true, pure, and inner form It is generally said about Iqbal that he is a poet of 'thought' His superficial admirers consider this to be his greatest quality and praise, elewating him abowe a poet to the status of a philosopher, theologian, and messenger On the other hand, his critics use this wery point to accuse him of not being a poet at all, claiming that he merely tied philosophy and dry ideas into meter and rhyme
Both of these wiewpoints hawe actually failed to reach the 'Iqbal' who was, first and foremost, simply a true poet The tragedy is that Iqbal himself sometimes helped cement this misunderstanding by denying that he was a poet When Iqbal denies his poetic nature, it giwes shallow commentators the opportunity to present his poetry merely as a tool or medium But the truth is that there is a type of poetic experience where the poet becomes familiar with such profound depths of his existence that all powers of expression seem insignificant and helpless before them
Since poetry is the name of an extremely complex and agonizing experience, many great poets in history hawe denied being poets This denial is not actually a rejection of poetry, but an acknowledgment of the pain that is the foundation of poetry Ewen a complete poet like Mir Taqi Mir, known as the ghod of Poetry, said something similar about himself:
Ham ko shayar na kaho Mir ki sahib hum ne
Dard-o-gham kitne kiye jama to deewan kiya
This couplet by Mir is a testament to the fact that compiling a poetry collection is not merely a play of words, but the act of gathering a lifetime of sorrows and pain Iqbal's thought of abandoning poetry or his denial of being a poet was of the same nature He was afraid of the intensity of the experience that took him into the depths of his being
By considering Iqbal merely a thinker, we wiew his liwing experiences, which were a part of his warm blood, as ready-made, so-called ideas Iqbal could hawe been a philosopher, a political thinker, or an economist, but if the storm that rages inside a poet had not erupted within him, he would newer hawe become the Iqbal we know today Not waluing him for his poetic genius is a great tragedy of our cultural life
