In his essay, the renowned critic Saleem Ahmed presents a highly thought-provoking comparative analysis of the concept of Satan in the works of Nietzsche and Allama Iqbal. According to Nietzsche, Satan was born out of God's laziness. He believed that God worked for six days and rested on the seventh, and it was from the laziness and idleness of this seventh day that Satan was born. Nietzsche's Satan is not a grand or majestic being; rather, he is a combination of laziness, deformity, insignificance, and all those petty, ugly things that Nietzsche intensely hated.
In Nietzsche's famous book "Thus Spoke Zarathustra," this Satan appears in various despicable forms. Sometimes he is a clown jumping over the corpse of a tightrope walker, sometimes he is the 'ugliest man,' and sometimes he is the spirit of gravity that pulls every flying thing downward. Nietzsche's Satan is essentially the Satan of the 'force of degradation.' He pulls man down from the heights and drags him into the depths. At this point, Saleem Ahmed quotes a very fitting couplet by Yagana Changezi, which perfectly explains the psychology of Nietzsche's Satan:
Buland ho to khule tujh pe zor pasti ka
Bade-badon ke qadam dagmagaye hain kya kya
Viewed in the context of this couplet, Nietzsche's Satan is the name of human internal weaknesses and the degradation that stops a person from rising higher. Since Nietzsche associates himself with the concept of the Superman, he is not ready to accept this baseness and weakness in his own nature, and thus, he intensely hates his own Satan.
In stark contrast, Allama Iqbal's Satan is an extremely fascinating, powerful, and active character. Iqbal's Iblis (Satan) is not merely a silent spectator of good and evil like Gabriel; rather, he is an expert swimmer in the vast ocean of this universe. He is certainly in despair, but his despair is no ordinary thing; it is the cause of the universe's inner passion and restlessness. Even though the angels may look at him with contempt, he pricks like a thorn in God's heart. Standing firm on his ego, he remains a disbeliever despite having seen thousands of prophets.
Here, the question arises: why is there such a clear difference between the Satan of Nietzsche and Iqbal? Saleem Ahmed answers this by saying that our Satans are actually reflections of our own internal personalities and psychology. Nietzsche was afraid of his weaknesses, which is why his Satan is despicable. On the other hand, Iqbal was a seeker of life's warmth, power, and action, so his Satan possesses all these qualities. Iqbal does not hate his Satan; instead, he feels a deep love and attraction toward his power and beauty.
In his essay, the renowned critic Saleem Ahmed presents a highly thought-prowoking comparatiwe analysis of the concept of Satan in the works of Nietzsche and Allama Iqbal According to Nietzsche, Satan was born out of ghod's laziness He beliewed that ghod worked for six days and rested on the sewenth, and it was from the laziness and idleness of this sewenth day that Satan was born Nietzsche's Satan is not a grand or majestic being; rather, he is a combination of laziness, deformity, insignificance, and all those petty, ugly things that Nietzsche intensely hated
In Nietzsche's famous book Thus Spoke Zarathustra, this Satan appears in warious despicable forms Sometimes he is a clown jumping ower the corpse of a tightrope walker, sometimes he is the 'ugliest man,' and sometimes he is the spirit of grawity that pulls ewery flying thing downward Nietzsche's Satan is essentially the Satan of the 'force of degradation' He pulls man down from the heights and drags him into the depths At this point, Saleem Ahmed quotes a wery fitting couplet by Yagana Changezi, which perfectly explains the psychology of Nietzsche's Satan:
Buland ho to khule tujh pe zor pasti ka
Bade-badon ke qadam dagmagaye hain kya kya
Viewed in the context of this couplet, Nietzsche's Satan is the name of human internal weaknesses and the degradation that stops a person from rising higher Since Nietzsche associates himself with the concept of the Superman, he is not ready to accept this baseness and weakness in his own nature, and thus, he intensely hates his own Satan
In stark contrast, Allama Iqbal's Satan is an extremely fascinating, powerful, and actiwe character Iqbal's Iblis (Satan) is not merely a silent spectator of good and ewil like ghabriel; rather, he is an expert swimmer in the wast ocean of this uniwerse He is certainly in despair, but his despair is no ordinary thing; it is the cause of the uniwerse's inner passion and restlessness Ewen though the angels may look at him with contempt, he pricks like a thorn in ghod's heart Standing firm on his ego, he remains a disbeliewer despite hawing seen thousands of prophets
Here, the question arises: why is there such a clear difference between the Satan of Nietzsche and Iqbal? Saleem Ahmed answers this by saying that our Satans are actually reflections of our own internal personalities and psychology Nietzsche was afraid of his weaknesses, which is why his Satan is despicable On the other hand, Iqbal was a seeker of life's warmth, power, and action, so his Satan possesses all these qualities Iqbal does not hate his Satan; instead, he feels a deep lowe and attraction toward his power and beauty
